KidzTalk

Mystery Box

+9 votes
576 views
asked Mar 20, 2013 in Challenge / Quizzes by whizkid (65,700 points)
You have 3 boxes. One has a great prize in it and the other 2 are bad ones. You pick a box at random, but you don't know if it is the prize. You are shown the content of another box that is a bad prize. One unopened box remains. Do you keep your original selection, or change to the unopened box? Does it make a difference?


9 Answers

+2 votes
answered Jul 21, 2014 by arkzo (424,180 points)

i would rather keep the original box i have

+2 votes
answered Mar 23, 2013 by jamesaly (720 points)
edited Mar 23, 2013 by jamesaly

You want to always switch the box. When you first pick the box, you had a 2 out 3 chance of losing (1 prize and 2 bad prizes). Your odds of winning are 1 in 3 or 33.33%. If you don't change your answer, this number can't change since the order of what is in the boxes does not change over time. However, If you switch boxes, your chance of losing is different. You now know which which box has one of the bad prizes, since it was shown to you, so you do not pick it (not allowed actually). There can only be one unknown bad prize remaining. The situation can now look like:
 

A. 1) bad, 2) bad 3) prize
B. 1) bad, 2) prize, 3) bad 
C. 1) prize, 2) bad 3) bad
 
There are no other combinations.
 
You can go over each situation. Lets say you always pick the first column.
For A
Picked bad, 2 shown to you. You switch and win.
 
For B
Picked bad, 3 shown to you. You switch and win.
 
For C
Picked prize. 2 or 3 shown to you. You switch and lose.
 
So you win 2/3 or 66.65% of the time. You can repeat this with each door as your selection and the match is the same.
 
If you don't switch the odds are only 33.33%, but if you switch it jumps to 66.67%.  It defies common sense, but the math works out. When you are given more info, like which box has one of the bad prizes, it changes the odds..

 

+2 votes
answered Mar 23, 2013 by niall luver (3,970 points)

I think it doesn't really matter but I personally would keep the original because I think that one is special!!!!! 

+2 votes
answered Mar 23, 2013 by Cupcake549 (32,490 points)
Stay with your first one because i am always told your first instinct is your best also you have a 50 50 chance!
commented Mar 26, 2013 by anonymous
Actually, you don't have a 50 50 chance. The probability is 66-33 chance.
commented Jun 19, 2013 by Cupcake549 (32,490 points)
How would that equal out because 66+33=99 and it needs to be 100
commented Sep 29, 2013 by AlterCinto (5,340 points)
66% and 33% are the percentage form of 2/3 and 1/3, respectively. You have three boxes, so that's how it adds up to 100%.

66% is actually .66666666666666666 (and on and on), so the lost 1% is in the repeating number.

...I think.
+2 votes
answered Mar 22, 2013 by mystic_beauty (17,920 points)
To me, I would just live with what I've got, because I've experienced that if you backtrack your decision, you fall in the ditch....

- CraftyGirlJuJu
+2 votes
answered Mar 22, 2013 by anonymous
no it doesn't make a difference because it could jst be an empty box
+2 votes
answered Mar 21, 2013 by smile828 (32,100 points)
I would just keep the first box you have.
+2 votes
answered Mar 21, 2013 by mathgeek36 (41,740 points)
I heard a problem like this before. I think you were suppose to keep the box you already have, because the probability will be lower if you choose the other box. I don't exactly remember, but hopefully this helps!
+4 votes
answered Mar 21, 2013 by anonymous
I would keep my origal box but it dose not matter I just have a hunch.

Related questions

+10 votes
4 answers 3,167 views
asked Mar 18, 2013 in Math by reptar (4,550 points)
+8 votes
3 answers 129 views
+9 votes
2 answers 281 views
asked Sep 12, 2016 in Challenge / Quizzes by sama (3,800 points)
+6 votes
1 answer 78 views
asked Jul 8, 2016 in Challenge / Quizzes by THE PORCUPINE SQUAD
+10 votes
2 answers 2,473 views
asked Oct 26, 2013 in Challenge / Quizzes by kidzsearch (138,370 points)
+12 votes
7 answers 4,814 views
asked Mar 13, 2013 in Challenge / Quizzes by kidzsearch (138,370 points)
+12 votes
3 answers 444 views
asked Mar 13, 2013 in Challenge / Quizzes by kidzsearch (138,370 points)
+12 votes
7 answers 8,386 views
+2 votes
1 answer 33 views
+10 votes
11 answers 148 views
+9 votes
12 answers 180 views
+9 votes
6 answers 178 views
asked Mar 22, 2018 in Technology by Friendsrule (51,370 points)
+7 votes
2 answers 141 views
asked Jan 15, 2018 in Other by NATHAN (63,600 points)
+6 votes
4 answers 154 views
asked Dec 26, 2016 in Technology by ShadowShy (2,050 points)
+10 votes
7 answers 185 views
asked Aug 28, 2016 in Other by Crosbyallday87
+9 votes
6 answers 273 views
asked Jan 5, 2016 in Fiction by GymnastPower (36,940 points)
+6 votes
2 answers 224 views
asked Nov 19, 2015 in Games / Toys by orangestfedora (3,180 points)
+6 votes
1 answer 69 views
asked Jan 11, 2019 in Other Contests by Catman365
+10 votes
1 answer 110 views
asked Oct 15, 2018 in Other by im kanye (372,930 points)
+9 votes
1 answer 85 views
+8 votes
3 answers 524 views
asked Jan 15, 2018 in Math by NATHAN (63,600 points)
+8 votes
2 answers 153 views
asked Nov 3, 2017 in Math by arkzo
+7 votes
1 answer 118 views
asked Oct 12, 2017 in Math by Friends come and go (3,300 points)

Recent Badges

Notable Question
Asked question received 50 views
- -Moonlight- -
Popular Question
Asked question received 100 views
- Lemony The Bean -
Popular Question
Asked question received 100 views
- PrincessKittens Left -
Nice Answer
Answer received +2 upvote
- kidzsearch -
Grateful
Selected 1 answer as best answer
- OllieMotionStudios -
...